A new study published in the Christmas issue of the British Medical Journal suggests that, while less graphic than a live-action gore fest, children’s animated films seem to feature plenty of violent death. In “Cartoons Kill!,” lead authors Dr. Ian Colman (University of Ottawa) and Dr. James Kirkbride (University College London) found that early classics and newer favorites could be considered “hotbeds for murder and mayhem” — an unusual twist for the usually light-hearted annual Journal issue.
“I’ve got two young kids and we’ve watched or tried to watch a lot of animated films and they became really scared by what they saw,” Colman told Canada’s Global News. “A great example is The Land Before Time. In the first five minutes the mother gets killed by a Tyrannosaurus Rex, and quite violently. My daughter was begging me to turn it off.”
The researchers reviewed 135 top-grossing North American films from 1937 (when Snow White was released) onward, comprised of 45 kid-targeted animated flicks and 90 adults-only dramatic films. The study looked at which genre was more likely to show a key character or significant family member/friend die, with surprising results. Colman told Global News the question was originally meant to be “funny.”
Colman and co found that a significant character was 2.5 times more likely to die in a children’s animated film — and that when a death occurs in animation, it’s at least 2.8 times more likely to be the result of murder and five times more likely to happen to a parent (see Bambi, Tarzan, The Lion King). The soonest into an animated film a death occurred is in 2003’s Finding Nemo, which sees Nemo’s mother and unborn siblings fall victim to a hungry barracuda in the first four minutes.
The authors concluded the paper by advising that parents watch movies with their kids and offer emotional support for “the inevitable horrors that will unfold.” Happy holidays!
This study I find to be completely and unnecessarily unfair. The fact is, any good story has to have some bumps along the way, and some stories call for bigger bumps than others. And I would frankly argue against the fact that any of these are “rife with violent death”; Nemo and Bambi were both off-screen and handled very well. And I think the most important thing to remember is that parents should ALWAYS view a film before their children do, so they’ll know whether their kid is ready for it or not. Perhaps it’s better for these parents to just let their kids watch Sofia and Dora until their parents feel they’re ready for more intense situations. Just my two cents.